|
|
Post by Andrew on Oct 28, 2006 10:07:16 GMT -5
The last of the first part. I added one bonus song, just to keep things even. Total number of songs is 104.
Terry found a mistake. It is in the final bracket...I have fixed it. Arjan, please vote on that one again! Thanks!
Won't end this until Tuesday night.
The Beatles: Revolution
vs
The Beatles: Help!
Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo
vs
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi
Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo
vs
Wings: Silly Love Songs
The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever
vs
George Harrison: Dark Horse
The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand
vs
The Beatles: Paperback Writer
The Beatles: Norwegian Wood
vs
John Lennon: Mind Games
George Harrison: Blow Away
vs
Wings: Goodnight Tonight
The Beatles: Come Together / Something
vs
The Beatles: Lady Madonna
Ringo Starr: Only You
vs
Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show
The Beatles: Let It Be
vs
Wings: Jet
The Beatles: She Loves You
vs
George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You
Wings: I've Had Enough
vs
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night
vs
The Beatles: Yesterday
The Beatles: All You Need is Love
vs
The Beatles: Please Please Me
The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue
vs
Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why
Paul McCartney: Press
vs
The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet
The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby
vs
Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run
The Beatles: Across the Universe
vs
George Harrison: You
|
|
|
|
Post by arjan on Oct 28, 2006 10:14:16 GMT -5
The Beatles: Revolution
vs
The Beatles: Help!
Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo
vs
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi
Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo
vs
Wings: Silly Love Songs
The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever
vs
George Harrison: Dark Horse
The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand
vs
The Beatles: Paperback Writer
The Beatles: Norwegian Wood
vs
John Lennon: Mind Games
George Harrison: Blow Away
vs
Wings: Goodnight Tonight
The Beatles: Come Together / Something
vs
The Beatles: Lady Madonna
Ringo Starr: Only You
vs
Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show
The Beatles: Let It Be
vs
Wings: Jet
The Beatles: She Loves You
vs
George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You
Wings: I've Had Enough
vs
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night
vs
The Beatles: Yesterday
The Beatles: All You Need is Love
vs
The Beatles: Please Please Me
The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue
vs
Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why
Paul McCartney: Press
vs
The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet
The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby
vs
Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run
The Beatles: Across the Universe
vs
George Harrison: You
|
|
|
|
Post by jhar26 on Oct 28, 2006 10:54:27 GMT -5
The Beatles: Revolution vs The Beatles: Help!  close! Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo vs Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo vs Wings: Silly Love Songs by defaultThe Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever vs George Harrison: Dark Horse The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand vs The Beatles: Paperback Writer The Beatles: Norwegian Wood vs John Lennon: Mind Games George Harrison: Blow Away vs Wings: Goodnight Tonight The Beatles: Come Together / Something vs The Beatles: Lady Madonna Ringo Starr: Only You vs Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show The Beatles: Let It Be vs Wings: Jet The Beatles: She Loves You vs George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You Wings: I've Had Enough vs The Beatles: Eight Days a Week John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night vs The Beatles: Yesterday The Beatles: All You Need is Love vs The Beatles: Please Please Me The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue vs Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why Paul McCartney: Press vs The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby vs Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run The Beatles: Across the Universe vs George Harrison: You Gaston |
|
|
|
Post by egoodstein on Oct 29, 2006 17:18:03 GMT -5
The Beatles: Revolution
vs
The Beatles: Help!
Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo
vs
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi
Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo
vs
Wings: Silly Love Songs
**Dislike both really.
The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever
vs
George Harrison: Dark Horse
**Fave of a type.
The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand
vs
The Beatles: Paperback Writer
**Super fave.
The Beatles: Norwegian Wood
vs
John Lennon: Mind Games
George Harrison: Blow Away
vs
Wings: Goodnight Tonight
The Beatles: Come Together / Something
vs
The Beatles: Lady Madonna
**A real fave. Like CT, not Something.
Ringo Starr: Only You
vs
Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show
The Beatles: Let It Be
vs
Wings: Jet
**I don't much like LIB.
The Beatles: She Loves You
vs
George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You
Wings: I've Had Enough
vs
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night
vs
The Beatles: Yesterday
**Tempted to pass. Bored w. Yesterday.
The Beatles: All You Need is Love
vs
The Beatles: Please Please Me
**I like Magical Mystery Tour.
The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue
vs
Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why
**Another Day is a fave Paul song of mine. don't like LAWR that much.
Paul McCartney: Press
vs
The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet
The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby
vs
Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run
**Like both.
The Beatles: Across the Universe
vs
George Harrison: You
Ed
|
|
|
|
Post by Antonio on Oct 30, 2006 11:56:47 GMT -5
The Beatles: Revolution vs The Beatles: Help! Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo vs Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo vs Wings: Silly Love Songs The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever vs George Harrison: Dark Horse The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand  vs The Beatles: Paperback Writer The Beatles: Norwegian Wood vs John Lennon: Mind Games George Harrison: Blow Away vs Wings: Goodnight Tonight The Beatles: Come Together / Something vs The Beatles: Lady Madonna Ringo Starr: Only You vs Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show The Beatles: Let It Be vs Wings: Jet The Beatles: She Loves You vs George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You Wings: I've Had Enough vs The Beatles: Eight Days a Week John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night vs The Beatles: Yesterday The Beatles: All You Need is Love vs The Beatles: Please Please Me The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue vs Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why Paul McCartney: Press vs The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby vs Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run The Beatles: Across the Universe vs George Harrison: You |
|
|
|
Post by Andrew on Oct 31, 2006 9:48:37 GMT -5
Just a reminder that I'll be closing this at around 5 pm mountain time (7 eastern, 4 pacific, dunno in England, etc.) today. I'll tally the votes tonight, and then post the first part of round 2. The songs which got caught up in my mistake will automatically move into the next round, just to be as fair as I can at this point. Those would be George Harrison's Blow Away and The Beatles' Across the Universe. I'll put them against each other in a bracket.
Andrew (still time to vote, in other words!)
|
|
|
|
Post by Andrew on Nov 1, 2006 20:52:40 GMT -5
I never voted on this:
The Beatles: Revolution *****
vs
The Beatles: Help!
Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo *****
vs
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi
Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo
vs
Wings: Silly Love Songs *****
The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever *****
vs
George Harrison: Dark Horse
The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand
vs
The Beatles: Paperback Writer *****
The Beatles: Norwegian Wood *****
vs
John Lennon: Mind Games
George Harrison: Blow Away
vs *****PASS*****
Wings: Goodnight Tonight
The Beatles: Come Together / Something *****
vs
The Beatles: Lady Madonna
Ringo Starr: Only You
vs
Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show *****
The Beatles: Let It Be *****
vs
Wings: Jet
The Beatles: She Loves You *****
vs
George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You
Wings: I've Had Enough
vs
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week *****
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night *****
vs
The Beatles: Yesterday
The Beatles: All You Need is Love *****
vs
The Beatles: Please Please Me
The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue *****
vs
Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why
Paul McCartney: Press
vs *****PASS*****
The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet
The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby
vs
Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run *****
The Beatles: Across the Universe *****
vs
George Harrison: You
|
|
|
|
Post by Andrew on Nov 1, 2006 21:27:55 GMT -5
The results.
The Beatles: Revolution 7
vs
The Beatles: Help! 7***
Ringo Star: Back Off Boogaloo 4
vs
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi 9***
Ringo Starr: No No Song / Snookeroo 4
vs
Wings: Silly Love Songs 9***
The Beatles: Strawberry Fields Forever 10***
vs
George Harrison: Dark Horse 3
The Beatles: I Want to Hold Your Hand 5
vs
The Beatles: Paperback Writer 10 ***
The Beatles: Norwegian Wood 11***
vs
John Lennon: Mind Games 3
George Harrison: Blow Away 10 ***
vs
Wings: Goodnight Tonight 1
The Beatles: Come Together / Something 10***
vs
The Beatles: Lady Madonna 5
Ringo Starr: Only You 3
vs
Wings: Venus and Mars Rock Show 8***
The Beatles: Let It Be 7
vs
Wings: Jet 8***
The Beatles: She Loves You 11***
vs
George Harrison: Got My Mind Set On You 3
Wings: I've Had Enough 1
vs
The Beatles: Eight Days a Week 13***
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You Through the Night 9***
vs
The Beatles: Yesterday 5
The Beatles: All You Need is Love 6
vs
The Beatles: Please Please Me 9***
The Beatles: The Long and Winding Road / For You Blue 9***
vs
Paul McCartney: Another Day / Oh Woman Oh Why 3
Paul McCartney: Press 2
vs
The Beatles: Ain't She Sweet 9***
The Beatles: Eleanor Rigby 9***
vs
Paul McCartney and Wings: Band on the Run 5
The Beatles: Across the Universe -- I didn't tally this one. I'm going to put this exact same matchup in the next Round so it can get a fair vote. Unfortunately, neither will get points from Round 1 (in the final tally) because of my screw-up, but theoretically either one can still win the very last bracket, ironically.
vs
George Harrison: You
|
|
